Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
Anti-Fluttershy stamp by Ramen11111 Anti-Fluttershy stamp by Ramen11111
EDIT: Bronies. This stamp is really, really old. You can favorite/comment/rage whatever but I'm just warning you I may not be able to reply to you if you comment... Honestly, I still don't like Fluttershy much, but she's never gotten in the way of my love of the show. So please respect my opinion. Love and tolerate.

Don't get me wrong, I like the MLP series and most of it's characters. To say that I HATE fluttershy is an overstatment. However, Fluttershy comes off as a sue in my opinion. She became a model, told off a dragon, wrestled a bear, has no flaws other then fear, which only comes off as "cute" to the fans. Not to mention she's so overrated. And yet whenever I state my opinion, people get all butthurt and actually start INSULTING ME. Someone on youtube called me blunt and overbearing. What gives you the right to insult someone's character based off an opinion of a CHARACTER? If I don't like Hinata from Naruto, that must mean I'm a rude person. (By the way I do like Hinata anyways.)

And even if you consider her shyness a flaw, she overcomes it SO EASILY. It's entirely unrealistic.

Everyone is entitled to thier opinions, and if I happen to state mine, it should be as fine as you stating yours. You aren't actually practicing love and tolerance at all if you act like that. While I do enjoy the series some of the fans are totally immature.

Oh, and I happen to LIKE Gilda. I think she was a neat and open-ended character with flaws... but nope. The moment she was mean to Fluttershy, all hell breaks lose.

I'm aware of the fact that very few people agree with me. I think this is because most of Flutterhy's fans think she's cute, so of course real flaws don't matter. Yes, a lot of the ponies are stereotypical... but at least they have flaws... and I don't consider Fluttershy's dark side a flaw. Instead it makes her more overrated. The "shy but dark inside" thing has been so overrused it's basically a dead horse trope (no pun intended).

I also really like this comment by ErikaDaniel98 , they sum up what I said in a different way,

"Being too nice isn't a real flaw, first, second, it sometimes means an unrealistic character.
I'll tell you why she's unrealistic:
I was shy and she's three times the shy person I was.
I couldn't even THINK of:
1.Yelling at and beating up the whole town.
2.Overcoming my shyness so easily(in 'Dragonshy', 'Stare Master', 'Putting your Hoof down')
3.Turning into a 'bitch' for no reason('Flutterbitch' is NOT one of her flaws. Because it proves she overcomes her shyness within seconds.)
So imagine how unrealistic FS's character is. Also, 'the stare'? Excuse me, I can see RAINBOW DASH or CELESTIA having it, but Fluttershy? NO. No way in HELL. That's not how it works in reality.
I've also asked plently of shy people. They agreed with me, and said they could never relate to Fluttershy.
If you're gonna go against that, then hun, you must believe people are perfect.
Also, MS's are characters who are fawned by men. 'Fawned by men' is pretty much equal to 'Never gets the blame' here, because there's a rare appearance of stallions in the show. And she never does. In 'Putting your hoof down' they blamed Iron Will for FS's bad behaviour, while it was FS's fault.
As a FLUTTERSHY FAN said:
"That's not how it works. You can't blame abusing skills thaught to you by your teacher on your teacher, especially when they work. That's like saying someone teaches me to use a gun, I kill someone with said gun, but according to this episode's logic, it's not MY fault, it's my teacher's. And does she pay him at the end? No, she sends him away because of his terrible leasons, which had nothing to do with how she treated her friends. How you choose to use your what you've learned is your own damn decision, not Iron Will's."
Ahem, ahem. If that doesn't SCREAM Mary-sue or at least the most fucking unrealistic character in the entire show, then I don't know what it is."
Add a Comment:
 
:iconnexus639:
Nexus639 Featured By Owner Apr 13, 2017  Student Digital Artist
Well, I don't mind at all
Reply
:iconforceofnatureandcorn:
forceofnatureandcorn Featured By Owner Jul 1, 2016  Hobbyist Writer
Reply
:iconkenny7mccormick:
Kenny7Mccormick Featured By Owner 5 days ago  Hobbyist General Artist
Reply
:iconsuperjordanblast:
SuperJordanBlast Featured By Owner Apr 26, 2016  Hobbyist Artist
She is WAAAY to shy now ( Like in the ep when she took part in nightmare night )


Fluttershy : But what if one of the gums stick my teath together and I cant speak?

Me : YOUR JOKING RIGHT??


also the fans COMPELTLY ruined her for me. Making her mean, secretly a physco....
Reply
:iconminidirensushi:
MiniDirenSushi Featured By Owner Edited Apr 24, 2016  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I happen to like Fluttershy and I understand your opinion.
On the other hand, the rabid fans make me cringe and I feel so ashamed to be a Fluttershy fan.
Reply
:iconflummyflumox:
FlummyFlumOx Featured By Owner Mar 13, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
I personally love FLuttershy but I see what you're coming from. I do give her more of a personality and flows, as I do not like how shes sort of a mary sue.
Reply
Flagged as Spam
:iconcorajbae09:
corajbae09 Featured By Owner Edited Feb 28, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
How about "opinions" butt hurt brony:iconcoralineheaddeskplz: mlp teaches friendship right? And you guys are over here yelling at others if they don't like a certain pony.oh well
:iconfluttershyniceplz:

:iconmamabearfacepalmplz:
Reply
:iconramen11111:
Ramen11111 Featured By Owner Feb 21, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
lol. this stamp was from years ago I no longer care about the topic. 
Reply
:iconzerowizard:
ZeroWizard Featured By Owner Jan 6, 2016
Even though I don't necessarily hate Fluttershy, I think she is so overpraised by the fandom that I've actually come up with a nickname to describe her immense hype: Flutter Christ. Specifically, a perfect little saint who can do no wrong.
Reply
:iconawesomestarz:
awesomestarz Featured By Owner Jan 2, 2016  Student Traditional Artist
Fluttershy was one of my favorite ponies, but now she has moved down a rung or two because I don't relate to her as much anymore. I like rainbow dash more because she actually developed more as the series progressed.
Reply
:iconilikefennekin111:
ILikeFennekin111 Featured By Owner Sep 5, 2015
DERPY IS LOVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DERPY IS LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply
:icontherealcuddles:
TheRealCuddles Featured By Owner Aug 10, 2015
Pinkie and Twi are better.
Reply
:iconx-jenny-9:
X-Jenny-9 Featured By Owner Aug 2, 2015
There's this guy I know I think it was ShutterflyEQD made his OC just so it could have sex with Fluttershy.

Stuff like this makes me hate this fanbase
Reply
:icondunsparce077:
dunsparce077 Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2015
yes

god damn, get some self-esteem and redeeming qualities
Reply
:iconfoxyloxykrabbe:
foxyloxykrabbe Featured By Owner Jun 18, 2015  Student General Artist
to be honest my favorite charactor is pinkie pie so I can agree a little bit to this.
Reply
:iconsupermariofan:
SuperMarioFan Featured By Owner Jun 15, 2015
Please. Even those of us that are shy can have moments in which we overcome our shyness, especially if it means to help our friends (Dragonshy) as well as moments in which we blow up and say cruel things that we don't really mean. Hasn't that happened to all of us at some point or another? So tell me who's REALLY being unrealistic. -_-
Reply
:icondoux-berry:
Doux-Berry Featured By Owner Aug 21, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Yes, we say 'cruel' things sometimes, but we don't push them around, tell someone they're no worth living, be a bully, then BLAME IT ON SOMEONE ELSE. 
and she's just a bipolar and selfish bitch..
Reply
:iconsupermariofan:
We've all acted that way and said horrible things like that when we're in a bad mood and/or really pissed off at someone else. Accept it and get the hell over it.
Reply
:icondoux-berry:
Doux-Berry Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
That's ENTIRELY false. I've never done that. My friends have never done that. Barely anyone has told someone their not worth living, and she wasn't even pissed off when she said those. She was just being a bully. And instead of confessing to it, she BLAMED SOMEONE ELSE.
shes a horrible character and role model for kids tbh. 
Now "accept it and get the hell over it". 
Reply
:iconsupermariofan:
SuperMarioFan Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015
Right. So because you and your friends have never said something that extreme at any point when they were mad, it means no one at all has done it either. Get over yourself and stop this bullshit.
Reply
:icondoux-berry:
Doux-Berry Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Bullshit? Bullshit of hating a shitty character? LMAO.
and it's not only me. I've never met someone who does that.
my family doesn't at ALL. and I have a big one. 
Maybe you're just the jerk like bitchy Fluttershy. Applejack liar 
Reply
:iconsupermariofan:
SuperMarioFan Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015
Oh yeah. Because she was mean in one episode automatically means she doesn't try to be kind in other episodes. Let's all hold a grudge against a character over a couple of bad moments which automatically outweigh their better moments!
Reply
:icondoux-berry:
Doux-Berry Featured By Owner Aug 22, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Better moments? You mean the other ones where she's actaully KIND? Well, it's hard to find one of those. She's just a bipolar brat in the new seasons. She's barely even shy anymore. 
Reply
(2 Replies)
:iconmellorox9:
mellorox9 Featured By Owner Edited Jun 8, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I don't hate her, but I can see why some people do. She gets a crazy amount of spotlight from the fans, I presume she's like the Marceline or Itachi of the series.

And props for being able to explain your dislike towards Fluttershy without insulting shy people in the process :) Most people can't seem to hate on characters like Fluttershy or Hinata without sounding like a total ass towards shy people who can't help it >.>
Reply
:iconcottencandie:
cottencandie Featured By Owner Jun 3, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
she's my least favorite in the Mane 6
Reply
:iconcrystal-okami:
Crystal-Okami Featured By Owner Apr 21, 2016  Student Digital Artist
same
Reply
:iconrabit2015:
Rabit2015 Featured By Owner May 29, 2015
Its not that I sometimes hate Fluttershy, It just that some fanfic authors can gave her unrealistic hippie behavior, like for example in cannon every pony knows that timber wolves are extremely hostile and predatory, yet those authors constantly endanger the character just to prove the point that kindness and suicidal behavior are above common sense and logic. 
Reply
:iconthelondonjamjar:
TheLondonJamJar Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Student General Artist
I do not like Fluttershy.
This person does not like Fluttershy
This is an opinion
No need to bash people for opinions
Love and tolerance, remember?
Reply
:iconladylitasparkle:
LadyLitaSparkle Featured By Owner May 21, 2015  Hobbyist
"Unrealistic" 

How funny, because we both know she doesn't exist.  
Reply
:iconthelondonjamjar:
TheLondonJamJar Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Student General Artist
If she doesn't exist, then why are you getting worked up about it?
Reply
:iconladylitasparkle:
LadyLitaSparkle Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Hobbyist
I never said I was my friend.
Reply
:iconthelondonjamjar:
TheLondonJamJar Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Student General Artist
What?
Reply
:iconladylitasparkle:
LadyLitaSparkle Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Hobbyist
I never said I was getting worked up over Fluttershy.

So lets end this now before it gets worse, agreed?
Reply
:iconthelondonjamjar:
TheLondonJamJar Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Student General Artist
Are you... seriously trying to threaten me?
Really now.
But okay, I respect your opinion, I just REALLY hate it when people get so angry when someone names a few flaws about a character.
G'day.
Reply
:iconladylitasparkle:
LadyLitaSparkle Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Hobbyist
:iconfacepalmplz: 

No no I wasn't threatening you, I meant lets end the ARGUMENT before it gets worse.
Reply
:iconthelondonjamjar:
TheLondonJamJar Featured By Owner May 22, 2015  Student General Artist
Okay, I really don't care right now, it was a misunderstanding.
Bye
Reply
(1 Reply)
:iconmynameiswaifu:
i like fluttershy. in fact, she's actually my favorite pony out of everyone in the mane six. but it's annoying as hell how people keep praising her and acting like she is a god, and bashing gilda over and over again over one thing: SHE MADE ALMIGHTY QUEEN FLUTTERSHY CRY. oh boo hoo hoo cry me a river and i'll fish in it. 

i understand all of the fellows in the comments and the fact that they hate her, it's almost impossible to NOT dislike her even a tiny bit after everything her fans have done (unless you were brainwashed).
Reply
:iconjeffsoul13:
Jeffsoul13 Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2015
A teacher is still responsable for tutoring students and planting them the 'ideas' in there head. If not teaching the person to use tgat weapon or skill properly, it can turn and bite them in the ass. Fluttershy, while still should be held accountable for her actions, still was misguided from the new found ability to assert herself. She got carried away from being power struck, and in any circumstance with any other character could also happen to them.

Examples: Twilight got carried away about pleasing her own desire towards her duties and in return, no only harmed herself but quite a few others.

Rainbowdash often lacks consideration towards her friends and 'blows' them off to what she wants.

Rarity has taken her friends for granted in the past, blowing them off for fashion runways or parties in general.

All of the main six have impulsive character moments and have self centered qualities.
Reply
:iconcolossaldick:
ColossalDick Featured By Owner Mar 20, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
This is perfect.
I hate Fluttershai.
Reply
:iconhuskeygirl3:
Huskeygirl3 Featured By Owner Mar 19, 2015  Hobbyist Writer
God bless this stamp, not only do fluttershy fanbrats go crazy when you point out her CHARACTER FLAWS. They always get the rest on the mane 6 personality wrong especially when they "hurt" fluttershy and it really upsets me. I personally find that Fluttershy CAN be intresting but her fans are just awful.
Reply
:iconchocorose555:
ChocoRose555 Featured By Owner Mar 18, 2015
a mary-sue is perfect and has magical powers that are godlike and dates the main character, all the main characters and has no flaws what so ever, so sorry Twilight and Rainbow Dash are more sue like, well Princess Twilight, cause she pretty much overshadows the mane six now as "best pony" cause it is either twilight or rainbow dash that have the most fans, this is why my best pony is now and will always will be Bon Bon, I still love Fluttershy, but you people need to stop this and just watch the show, and not hate the characters it is ridiculus, there will always going to be characters you dislike in a show, doesn't mean you should hate on them. This is why I like G1, and G3 :( cause g4 has gotten to extremist and fans will hate a character other fans like
Reply
:iconsugilita:
sugilita Featured By Owner Feb 25, 2015
:iconoverratedponyplz:
Reply
:iconnateflazh1000:
NateFlazh1000 Featured By Owner Jan 30, 2015
Yes Flutewrshy is my least favorite of the main 6
Reply
:iconlolsweetgirl:
lolsweetgirl Featured By Owner Jan 10, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
This I fully agree with
Reply
:iconpallygyrldashie:
PallygyrlDashie Featured By Owner Dec 26, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist
yus, i agree with this stamp >n?
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×




Details

Submitted on
June 20, 2012
Image Size
1.1 KB
Resolution
101×55
Link
Thumb
Embed

Stats

Views
12,546
Favourites
202 (who?)
Comments
751
Downloads
38
×